Michael Carvin: Profit From Improper Arrests

Posted by admin on Monday, January 9, 2017

Michael A. Carvin Money Quote saying charging ‘booking fees’ creates a profit motive for police to make arrests, whether justified or not they earn income. Michael A. Carvin said:
 

 

“The unilateral decision of a single police officer cannot possibly justify summarily confiscating money. Providing a profit motive to make arrests, gives officers an incentive to make improper arrests” — Michael A. Carvin

 

 

In this quote, Michael A. Carvin seems to be criticizing the practice of police confiscating money and property during arrests. The key points are:

• He argues that a “unilateral decision of a single police officer” is not sufficient justification on its own to allow for confiscating someone’s money or property.
• Carvin suggests this creates the risk of improper seizures made without sufficient oversight or review.
• He further states that allowing police to directly profit from money seized gives officers an “incentive to make improper arrests” in order to collect this money.
• This implies the profit motive could potentially encourage arrests made for the wrong reasons or without cause, rather than to enforce the law appropriately.

Overall, the quote conveys Carvin’s view that letting police confiscate and directly benefit from money and property seized from arrests poses problems and risks for civil liberties, due to the lack of checks and potential perverse incentives it could create.